SUkhanto Roy Associates Joint Venture, v. DCIT Cir 6,

CO 22/PUN/2010 | misc
Pronouncement Date: 16-12-2010 | Result: Dismissed

Appeal Details

RSA Number 2224523 RSA 2010
Bench Pune
Appeal Number CO 22/PUN/2010
Duration Of Justice 4 month(s) 13 day(s)
Appellant SUkhanto Roy Associates Joint Venture,
Respondent DCIT Cir 6,
Appeal Type Cross Objection
Pronouncement Date 16-12-2010
Appeal Filed By Assessee
Order Result Dismissed
Bench Allotted Not Allotted
Tribunal Order Date 16-12-2010
Assessment Year misc
Appeal Filed On 02-08-2010
Judgment Text
!'#!!$!!! %&'( ('))*++ -!.'))/0)1 '2 344++4!5 60& 7 2266! 8 $! 3++! + 9 0')%:!6;3!>/% 7 +2 ''( (')%) +; %&'( ('))* ++ -!.'))/0)1 $! 3++! + 7++?@ 9 0')%:!6;3 !>/% 8 '2 344++4!5 60& 7 +2 ' ! '! #$%&'& !'(! )* ! + ' -+ ./0 1! ! ' ! 2 ! ! '3$ 4 *$ ITA NO 162/PN/2009 & C.O. 22/PN/2010 SUKHANT ROY ASSOCIATES A.Y.2004 -05 PAGE OF 10 2 3$ 4 $2 1 -! 5647568 %& '% !' ! + + 9 #$ -$$ ! ! ! + !! 7 :/ ' 1! 3$;<% $ 4$ 3$7)<& + $ 8$ 7 7+1! 2+1! + : =>-+ ! 1! -+ ./07 ! #$%&'&'+ '1! $ 3$ 5$ 7 $$$ + 7 + ' !7 + !' ' -!$%&'&!! '' =>-+ $?+' 7 7! ! '! #$%&'& 1! -+ ./0 + @-+ ./ @=>- -+ ./0$ $2 ! ' ! + @=>- @-+ . / + '1! =>-! + $ .9=>- (! !+ $$$$-+' =>-7 ! ! 76A ITA NO 162/PN/2009 & C.O. 22/PN/2010 SUKHANT ROY ASSOCIATES A.Y.2004 -05 PAGE OF 10 3 ! ! + .9$ +! %6A ! + $ B-6A $$ ( ! ! =>-' $=>- !! ! .9 ! 4&$8 $ 7! ! ! 4&&& $ $ $$+' + 7%7&&& $ $$2 7 ! + .9 4& $ ! ! ! 4&&& $ 7 !!+ ' ! ' ' +! 767)%)#: $ $ !' $7 ! ! + $;&A )%$8&A$7 ! +1! 7+ ! ' 7 !+1! $ 6$ $C$77 1 ' $ *$ + +' ! 3 $ 3$4 * + 2+1! + $$2$. + $ C ! 7 1! ! @ -+ ./ 7 .$ 1! 4$&$4&&&7 !'' ! ! ! *$$4&&& !' 8$;$4&&8< 4$5$4&&5$ -+ ./ 1! + 1 @-$$! !' ( !$ -$$! 7 ITA NO 162/PN/2009 & C.O. 22/PN/2010 SUKHANT ROY ASSOCIATES A.Y.2004 -05 PAGE OF 10 4 $2$.$! + ' ! $ '9#$-$$! 44;*&$;5- $ ' $D!#%6&$ $' 457*&$;5 $' '!- 8$8$4&&$ + 5 -/ ! E$F$7 6*)&$8 $' + 48$4A $6;757*;&#:$ +3 ' -$$E$F ' +C-G-$$E$F+ 78&&$;5 $' $ 5*$45A $ 7557%8785&#:!#%6&6 $' + -$$! ;$64A $%*%5%8#:$ $2$ 1! ! 8 + H7'77C<= 4 !''$ 8 1! =!' !>/-! =>- ! + .9$ ! !''! !+ $2$ .$ ;$ $2 1! !' (! ! + .9=>- (! ! + $ ! )8* $ $ ! 4&&& $ $ 7 1 ! + 1! $$2 1! ! D!''! $ 7 !''! ! %4$)5 $' $ ! ! %*$%6 $' $ !''! ! ! 4&;$8& $' ! + + ! $ $4$4&&5$ ! !/ /C$E7 3$684#.3#&* ITA NO 162/PN/2009 & C.O. 22/PN/2010 SUKHANT ROY ASSOCIATES A.Y.2004 -05 PAGE OF 10 5 $I$4&&4:&87 ! '! #$%&'& ! 1! $ ' +1! + + $$ ! #$%&'&7 $+ ! ! ' 3$4+$ ! 7 ! @-+ ./ @=>- 1! $ 7 ' ! 7' =>-+ 1! !' #' #!#$%&#&'&&(#& %&) *+ &' && !& #& # -./%&)$ &&( &) #'*( +' # ()&(#&#%& -.'0$'& !' &) #' *( +(#!)$ &&(' # ## & !!(& ' &) #' 1 ### &)$% $) #!!$'!) '*( +&) #' ##$&$(&# #! %& #&#&#)##&&'!& &&' *( +&) #' '/ #&& '!& ) #' ::::::::::::::::::::::::: #&#'())% &(& -.'' &&% &()()& -.& & '2)! '&'!&&#&' () ' & & ! ' ! & #'*( +'& $)$& ITA NO 162/PN/2009 & C.O. 22/PN/2010 SUKHANT ROY ASSOCIATES A.Y.2004 -05 PAGE OF 10 6 ( ($ !& (& & & & '! &) #'*( +' ' 7 1' ''+ + + $2 ! / / C$E +1! !''! + $ +' ' + (' ! ! !' !!!$2. + 7%7&&& $ $2 ! +.9 4& $ $! ! ! 4&&& $ $ !!+ + ! +! 767)%)#: $ $ !' $ 7 ! ! + 0 $;&A )%$8&A$J ! !' !7 ! +1! $ +' -!$ %&'& ' ' K$ 0 0$ 7 !''! !! + ! ! ! !''! $I $4&&6:&*$!! $27 $$$I$4&&6:&* -!$ %&'& ''7 ! ! !''! ( 6A+ 4&& & $ $ ! $!''! ' ! ! + =!' !>/-! 0=>- ! .9 ! $7 7 7 !+ + ? .1! -+ ./0 !' ' ITA NO 162/PN/2009 & C.O. 22/PN/2010 SUKHANT ROY ASSOCIATES A.Y.2004 -05 PAGE OF 10 7 =>-+ L !-+ ./ ' ' ! ' ( =>-+ L ! ! =>-+ L !=>-+ L -+ ./'=>-+ 7 !'' ' !'' ! + + !! =>-+ $> ! ! =>- + 7 ( ! ! =>-+ ++ . -+ -+ ./1 ! 0$B 7 .9 ! ! ! =>- + ! 7 !! -+ ./1! $! ! =>-+ ' !''! ! ! $=>-+ 1! ! ! ' .97 .9 ' + - + ./1! $ - ! ! ' 7 ! $' $ 3$ ! $ 3$4 *1! $ %$ - 3$;<% 3$4 !!7 ! ' $ 2 -!$5647568%&'% :! ' ! ITA NO 162/PN/2009 & C.O. 22/PN/2010 SUKHANT ROY ASSOCIATES A.Y.2004 -05 PAGE OF 10 8 + +9#$-$$! ! 7 ! ! + $ !! 7/ ! ' 1! !! 7 ! + ' ! +! + $2$ ! -$$! 2. ' ! ! $ + $7 -!$564568 !+$ ! 3$% $47%$8%$5 7! ! 3'4 ))'#&'&&&' #( ' !)&($ &# #( # ( & # && !# && # & '! # &&&#'#5674 &%8' '&)&&)'!&'($%$ '#&($ %'# &&&! ($!& 9'(&&&' &(&%($ 2&&&&) 0''#&% !)&% ($-:&'';' 2&&#&&# &&%(-:&'';'2&& #& #&#(&&&'/53/3>?:9($#&)' ;&'/??/>:9 &1'''/)#&%&%;&'6>:9 &1''' %)'2&&&&)0''# &(# #&'& %&#()%() :5 '==/???&1'''#&# %' )&'!$ @;&'6>6:9 &1'''&!#&'#& #' ()' 2&&&&) 0''# %& ## ) !%#;%& #&& ! ' #1& %& !$ &(# &'